Our solution to problem 1.2.7
The 3-4-5 Triangle Hidden in Babylonian Clay
EDCP442 Assignment 1 · Problem 1.2.7 from 5000 Years of Geometry
(Scriba & Schreiber) ·
Group: Mahnaz, Hina, Izhar
For our first assignment, our group worked on an ancient puzzle: a single
line on a clay tablet almost 4,000 years old. Here is the background, how we
solved it in both the ancient and the modern way, and an extension to the
problem.
Background: A Line from Plimpton 322
Plimpton 322 is a small clay tablet from the Old Babylonian period
(around 1800 BC), probably from the city of Larsa in present-day southern Iraq.
It is now at Columbia University in New York. It lists 15 rows of numbers, and
each row describes a right-angled triangle with whole-number sides, more than a
thousand years before Pythagoras. The rows give the short side w, the
diagonal (hypotenuse) d, and a ratio in the first column. The long side h
is never written down.
Our problem asks us to look at row 11, the row with the smallest
numbers, which reads 33,45 | 45 | 1,15. Our task is to show that it is
the famous (3, 4, 5) triangle multiplied by one factor.

Row 11 of Plimpton
322, redrawn in cuneiform.
The key is the Babylonian number system. Scribes used only two signs, a
wedge for 1 and a hook for 10, and wrote numbers in base 60, just as we
still count minutes and seconds. So “1,15” is 1 sixty plus 15, which is 75,
like 1 hour 15 minutes. Crucially, they never wrote a “point”. The same signs
“1,15” can mean 75 or 1¼ (1;15, where we use “;” to mark the missing point),
and the problem hints that “1 can also mean 60”.
A small note/error in the problem: the book labels 33,45 as w²/d²,
but (45/75)² = 0.36, which does not match. It must be w²/h², which is
what the book’s own formula on p. 23 says.
Solution: The Ancient Way
We tried to use only the tools a Babylonian scribe had: base-60 numbers,
multiplication tables, reciprocal tables, and cut-and-paste geometry.
1.
Choose the scale. Scribes
liked to compare a figure with a unit side, so let the long side h = 1. The
tablet’s numbers then become w = 0;45 (¾) and d = 1;15 (1¼).
2.
Square w with a times table.
45 × 45 = (45 × 40) + (45 × 5) = 30,0 + 3,45 = 33,45. With the point, w²
= 0;33,45, which is exactly the first number on the tablet!
3.
Square d. Cut a square of
side 1;15 into four pieces (1 × 1, two strips of 1 × 0;15, and a small 0;15 ×
0;15 corner) and add them: 1 + 0;15 + 0;15 + 0;3,45 = 1;33,45.
4.
Find h by cut and paste.
Remove the square on w from the square on d. The leftover L-shape can be
rearranged into a rectangle that is (d + w) long and (d − w) wide: 2 × 0;30 = 1.
So, h² = 1 and h = 1. ✓
5.
Let “1” mean 60. Shift
every number one place (like turning hours into minutes) to get the whole
numbers 45, 60, 75.
6.
Divide by 15 the Babylonian
way. Scribes divided by multiplying by a reciprocal. The reciprocal of 15
is 0;4 (4 minutes is 1/15 of an hour), so 45 × 0;4 = 3, 60 × 0;4 = 4 and 75 ×
0;4 = 5.
Step 4: the L-shaped area d² − w²
becomes a (d + w) × (d − w) rectangle.
Solution: The Modern Way
With today’s
tools, the solution takes three lines:
d = 1,15 = 1 × 60 + 15 = 75, w = 45
h² = 75² − 45² = 5625 − 2025 = 3600, so h
= 60
gcd (45, 60, 75) = 15, so (45, 60, 75) = 15 × (3, 4, 5)
To check the first column, (45/60)² = 9/16 = 0.5625. Converting to base
60: 0.5625 × 60 = 33.75 gives the digit 33, and 0.75 × 60 = 45 gives the digit
45. So, 9/16 = 0;33,45, matching the tablet.
Row 11 is the 3-4-5 triangle scaled by
15. The long side, 60, is written as “1”.
Answer: row 11 is (45, 60, 75) = 15 × (3,
4, 5). Both methods agree. What struck us is that each modern step has an
ancient partner: the cut-and-paste rectangle is the formula d² − w² = (d + w)(d
− w), and scaling the long side to 1 is really thinking in ratios, the seed of
trigonometry.
Extension: Build Our Own Triangle
How might the scribe have made row 11? Historians think the scribe
started from a number and its partner: two numbers that multiply to give 1. For
row 11 the pair is 2 and 0;30, because 2 × 0;30 = 1 (two half-hours make an
hour). Then:
·
Average of the pair: (2 +
0;30) ÷ 2 = 2;30 ÷ 2 = 1;15 (half of 2 h 30 min is 1 h 15 min). This is d.
·
Half the difference: (2 −
0;30) ÷ 2 = 1;30 ÷ 2 = 0;45 (half of 1 h 30 min is 45 min). This is w.
These are exactly the tablet’s numbers! It works because d + w = 2 and d
− w = 0;30 are the two partners, and their product is 1. That is the same
rectangle as in Step 4.
Hence each row was built from a number x and its reciprocal (“igi”).
These are two numbers that multiply to give 1. The formula is:
d = ½ (x + igi x) w = ½ (x − igi x) h = 1
For row 11, x = 2 and igi 2 = 0;30. Then d = ½ (2 + 0;30) = 1;15 and w =
½ (2 − 0;30) = 0;45: exactly the tablet’s numbers! It works because (d + w)(d −
w) = x × igi x = 1, the same rectangle as in step 4.
We can try with
the other values below, then scale up to whole numbers and reduce:
|
x |
igi x |
d and w (h = 1) |
Triple |
|
2 |
0;30 |
d =
1;15, w = 0;45 |
15 × (3,
4, 5), row 11 |
|
1;30 (=
3/2) |
0;40 |
d =
1;05, w = 0;25 |
5 × (5,
12, 13) |
|
1;40 (= 5/3) |
0;36 |
d = 1;08, w = 0;32 |
4 × (8, 15, 17) |
|
2;15 (=
9/4) |
0;26,40 |
d =
1;20,50, w = 0;54,10 |
(65,
72, 97), row 5
of the tablet |
References
Scriba, C. J., & Schreiber, P. (2015). 5000 Years of Geometry.
Birkhäuser, pp. 22–26.
Neugebauer, O., & Sachs, A. (1945). Mathematical Cuneiform Texts.
American Oriental Society.
Robson, E. (2001). Neither Sherlock Holmes nor Babylon: A reassessment of
Plimpton 322. Historia Mathematica, 28(3), 167–206.
Robson, E. (2002). Words and pictures: New light on Plimpton 322.
American Mathematical Monthly, 109(2), 105–120.
Comments
Post a Comment